• DE&I Commitment
  • Careers
  • Locations
  • Book a Meeting
    Book a Meeting
  • Company
    Learn a little more about us, our values, and our team
    Our Values
    We don't just talk the talk; we live by our core values
    About Us
    Empowering brands to realize their potential with data, insights, and technology
    Leadership
    Meet our leadership team
    Secure Data Architecture
    Our promise of data security and privacy. We keep your data safe from publishers, competitors and bad actors
    Corporate Social Responsibility
    We are committed to making a positive impact on our communities and our planet
  • Platform
    Plan, manage, optimize, and measure your campaigns with our omnichannel platform
    Our Platform
    A platform that connects all walled garden media
    Connected Media
    Create and manage campaigns across search, social, retail media and apps, in one platform
    Connected Data
    Make data-driven decisions as you plan and strategize
    See the industries we serve
    Learn how our customizable solutions can help with your unique needs
    Explore our partner integrations
    See the media, retailer, and data partners we work with
  • Clients
  • News and Events
    Check out recent announcements and see what we’re up to
    News
    Check out our recent media coverage
    Events
    Join us for our next conference or webinar
    Omnichannel platform launch
    Read the press release to see how we're helping marketers win the walled gardens
    Let's talk omni at Shoptalk!
    Learn how our omnichannel platform can help you build a winning strategy
  • Resources
    From new releases, to industry trends and best practices, Skai has you covered
    Blog
    Read the latest insights and thought leadership from our industry experts
    Capabilities
    Take your campaigns to the next level by enhancing your platform capabilities
    Research
    Explore our reports and whitepapers so you can keep up on the latest industry trends
    Subscribe
    Sign up to get the latest updates straight to your inbox
    Quarterly Trends Report
    Learn digital advertising campaign performance trends from Q4 2022
Back to Blog

The Skai 5: Five Challenges Of Walled Garden Advertising and How to Solve Them

Joshua Dreller, Sr. Director, Content Marketing @ Skai™

February  13, 2023

With the rise of digital advertising, marketers have had to figure out how to maximize their reach and return on investment in an increasingly fragmented market. One way to do this is through walled garden advertising, which can come with significant challenges. 

In this article, we’ll be taking a look at these walled garden challenges and how best to approach them.

Walled garden advertising 101

In digital advertising, a walled garden refers to a giant publisher operating in a closed ecosystem in which it controls all of its activity and processes. Good examples of these include Google Ads, Meta Ads, Amazon Ads, etc. 

According to eMarketer, around 80% of U.S. digital advertising dollars is spent with walled garden publishers. While each walled garden is very different from the other, generally, we see three core characteristics that enable their many benefits:

Massive user bases. Some walled garden publishers have millions or billions of monthly average users. Even comparatively smaller walled garden publishers have a sizable monthly user base, like Snapchat (530+ million) and TikTok (1.8 billion).

Logged-in users across devices. Tracking users online fuels many advanced marketing tactics: personalization, ad targeting, measurement, and optimization. With new limitations on consumer data tracking, walled garden publishers can enable these critical use cases as they track their logged-in users behind the walls. 

Engaging native ad formats. While the open web offers a tremendous scale of ad inventory, the creative options are minimal. However, because walled gardens have complete control over ad placements, they can provide innovative formats that take full advantage of the online environment and tend to work much better than basic ads.

Five walled garden challenges for marketers

Even though advertising through the walled gardens provides tremendous benefits, there are still some hurdles that marketers must overcome.

They are called walled gardens for a reason

The walls of the walled gardens are a challenge for data exchange, as they protect users and their data from potential harm. The average consumer concerned about being tracked may need to realize that marketers cannot directly target them. Instead, advertisers set rules for their campaigns that the publishers fulfill for them anonymously.

A consistent criticism that marketers have had of the walled gardens for years is getting data in and out. Marketers need to get critical insights out and get data in to power their campaigns more effectively.

Getting data out. Walled gardens have treasure troves of data that marketers would love to have. These platforms have a wealth of information about what is taking place on retailer digital shelves, insights into which brands are winning ad auctions, and the market share of individual keywords/products. While advertisers have managed to gain some access to this data over time, they only have access to a limited portion of it. The primary issue is that these proprietary datasets give the publishers a unique advantage, making them desirable brand partners. As a result, publishers are not motivated to fully share their data with marketers. 

Getting data in. The same walls protecting user privacy from getting out also limit how brands can get data in. While there are some ways walled gardens have enabled marketers to use their zero and first-party data, these tactics fall a bit short of how advertisers would truly bring their proprietary data to bear if given the opportunity. With the new limitations on consumer data tracking, marketers are prioritizing their data assets to ready themselves for the data-less future; they need their walled garden partners to open up new lanes to leverage these datasets and not let their own walls get in the way. 

“The next phase is getting a signal into the walled gardens because that’s where we don’t have the visibility,” says Marc Pritchard, Chief Brand Officer, Proctor & Gamble.

Measurement is excellent within a walled garden but could be better across them

Walled gardens are closed ecosystems, so each publisher can track every ad exposure to actions within its walls even if a user accesses the publishers differently—devices, browsers, etc. Additionally, by tagging a website with the walled garden’s tracking code, the publisher can connect those ad exposures to actions on a brand’s website to drive performance optimization. This is very much a closed-loop measurement approach, which works well.

However, most brands’ conversions consist of numerous ad exposures across publishers—sometimes scores of them. Thus, ultimately, walled gardens make gaining a holistic view of how customers have interacted with campaigns across multiple platforms much more difficult.

These walls also limit advertisers as they work across different walled gardens. For example, setting frequency caps for ad exposure is quickly done within a single-walled garden, but executing the same across multiple-walled gardens becomes extremely difficult, if possible. As a result, if a marketer were to set a frequency limit of four exposures across 10 walled gardens, they might end up showing 40 ads to the same person. 

Zero exclusivity: your competitors can work with them too

One of the great things about walled gardens is that there’s a very low barrier to entry. Most have free, easily accessible, and intuitive ad systems where anyone can create an account with a credit card. So, while your brand can take advantage of the benefits of working with walled garden advertising, so can your rivals. 

For example, with Google Search Ads, your competitors can bid on your brand’s keywords, such as your company name, product names, etc. When consumers search on Google for your company, they may see ads from other companies triggered by your brand name. This is where a savvy rival can swoop in and steal customers.   

And because walled gardens have garnered so much marketer attention is, the reality that walled garden ad costs continue to rise. Most of these are auction-based channels, so the market sets the prices—with more competition, the prices go up. Marketers who plan to continue leveraging walled gardens as the majority of their budgets must find ways to keep costs low in order to remain efficient. 

The complexity of working with so many publishers

Each walled garden publisher has its own ad system with its own nuances, meaning you have to learn each platform separately. You can do some things with certain publishers that you can’t do with others. There are even different names for the same things. For example, the metric ad impressions may be called imps, served impressions, or other terms. 

Because they don’t integrate with each other, even simple tasks take more time than they should. If you wanted, for example, to pause a campaign, you have to go into each and every publisher’s backend system and do that separately. 

Aggregate insights aren’t so simple to reach

At any given moment, your boss, stakeholders, or clients may ask you to report on critical metrics and other information from your marketing. A typical example of this is pulling spend. A client may want to know exactly how much of the media budget has been spent that quarter. If you’re working with 10 walled garden publishers, you would have to go into the ad systems of each publisher, run reports for the date range requested, import the data into a spreadsheet, and then add everything together. 

While this isn’t an arduous task, it can be time-consuming. Then what if, the very next day, they want to know how many clicks they received yesterday? You would have to go through the same process again.

And although adding more time to a marketer’s day may be a slight annoyance, the real-world net effect of this issue is that teams will be less apt to act if they have a hunch. They may not have the time to pull and aggregate these reports on a gut feeling—but we all know that its these moments of inspiration is when groundbreaking ideas are formed.

Solving the walled garden challenges with technology to maximize the benefits

The fact that 80% of digital advertising is spent on walled gardens is enough evidence to show that marketers find value in them.

Here are just 10 of the benefits from the recent Skai report, Why walled gardens are a marketer’s best bet:

  1. Massive audience reach and scale
  2. The ability to utilize powerful, first-party data
  3. Free, out-of-the-box native audiences
  4. Accurate, intrachannel measurement
  5. Seamless native ad formats and placements
  6. Unparalleled advertising control
  7. Robust vendor ecosystems
  8. Performance-based ad costs
  9. Native algorithmic optimization
  10. Not reliant on cookies

How do marketers take advantage of these great benefits while bypassing or reducing the challenges presented in this article? 

The answer is technology. Specifically, marketers should consider third-party vendors that integrate with the walled garden publishers to offer functionality beyond the native platforms to deliver enhancements across the board.

When marketers were asked if they preferred the native platform plus third-party platforms versus the native platform alone, they affirmed the value of partner technology more than 2 to 1.


If you’re investing a significant portion of your budget into walled garden advertising, consider a third-party platform like Skai to help you accentuate the positives and reduce the negatives.

For more information about how Skai can help you connect the walls of the walled gardens, please reach out today and schedule a brief demo.

Request a Demo of Skai

Related Posts

  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – January 2023
    Read More
  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – December 2022
    Read More
  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – November 2022
    Read More
  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – April 2022
    Read More
  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – September 2022
    Read More
  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – June 2022
    Read More
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share via Email
  • Copy Link
    Copied!
Tags: Apps, Data, Data & Insights, Local, Measure, Optimize, Retail Media, Search, Social, xTLx

Subscribe to Updates

Media that matters.
Marketing that works.
© 2023 Kenshoo, Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy. Cookie Policy. Recruitment Privacy Policy.
  • Connected Data
    • Market Intelligence
    • Our Approach
    • By Need
    • By Solution
  • Connected Strategy
    • Dynamic Marketing Mix
    • Budget Forecasting
    • Strategic Consulting
  • Connected Media
    • Overview
    • Retail Media
    • Paid Search
    • Paid Social
    • App Marketing
    • Auditing
    • Expert Services
  • Measurement
    • Incrementality
    • Experiments
    • Cross-Channel Attribution
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Glossary
    • Case Studies
    • Training & Enablement
    • Developer Hub
Privacy Preference

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential, while others help us to improve this website and your experience.

Privacy Preference

Save All

Save

Accept Only Essential Cookies

Manage Cookie Preferences

Cookie Details Privacy Policy Imprint

Privacy Preference

Here you will find an overview of all cookies used. You can give your consent to whole categories or display further information and select certain cookies.

Save All Save Accept Only Essential Cookies

Back

Privacy Preference

Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Name
Provider Owner of this website, Imprint
Purpose Saves the visitors preferences selected in the Cookie Box of Borlabs Cookie.
Host(s) .skai.io, skai.io
Cookie Name borlabs-cookie
Cookie Expiry 1 Year
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Purpose This cookie stores selections made by the user in the Accessibe tool in order to maintain those settings on future visits. These cookies help us make our website compliant with our obligations under US law.
Privacy Policy https://accessibe.com/privacy-policy
Cookie Name acsbState, acsbReset
Cookie Expiry n/a
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Host(s) skai.io
Cookie Name wordpress_sec_,wordpress_test_cookie,wp-postpass_*, wordpresspass_*, wordpressuser_*
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year

We use these cookies to enhance functionality and allow for personalisation, such as live chats, videos and the use of social media.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Accept
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Host(s) .chilipiper.com, skai.chilipiper.com
Cookie Name fs_uid, CHILI_PIPER_CLUSTER, guest-session, _sp_ses*, _sp_id*
Cookie Expiry Session / 2 Years
Accept
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Host(s) .comeet.co, www.comeet.co
Cookie Name visid_incap_, nlbi_#######, incap_ses_, referrer22_00a, incap_ses_1364_2167377
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year
Accept
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Host(s) skai.io
Cookie Name moduleFormPardotDownload
Cookie Expiry 30 days

Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us to understand how our visitors use our website.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Accept
Name
Provider Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
Purpose Cookie by Google used for website analytics. Generates statistical data on how the visitor uses the website.
Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
Cookie Name _ga,_ga_*,_gat,_gat_*,_gid
Cookie Expiry 2 Months
Accept
Name
Provider Hotjar Ltd., Dragonara Business Centre, 5th Floor, Dragonara Road, Paceville St Julian's STJ 3141 Malta
Purpose Hotjar is an user behavior analytic tool by Hotjar Ltd.. We use Hotjar to understand how users interact with our website.
Privacy Policy https://www.hotjar.com/legal/policies/privacy/
Host(s) *.hotjar.com
Cookie Name _hjClosedSurveyInvites, _hjDonePolls, _hjMinimizedPolls, _hjDoneTestersWidgets, _hjIncludedInSample, _hjShownFeedbackMessage, _hjid, _hjRecordingLastActivity, hjTLDTest, _hjUserAttributesHash, _hjCachedUserAttributes, _hjLocalStorageTest, _hjptid, _hjSessionUser_2229986, _hjIncludedInPageviewSample, _hjIncludedInSessionSample, _hjAbsoluteSessionInProgress, _hjFirstSeen
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year

Marketing cookies are used by third-party advertisers or publishers to display personalized ads. They do this by tracking visitors across websites.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Accept
Name
Provider Linkedin
Cookie Name lidc, li_gc, lang, AnalyticsSyncHistory, UserMatchHistory, li_sugr, bcookie, TDCPM, TDID, bscookie, ln_or
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year
Accept
Name
Provider Skai
Accept
Name
Provider 6sense
Cookie Name _gd_session, _an_uid, _gd_visitor, _gd_svisitor, 6suuid
Cookie Expiry Session / 400 Days
Accept
Name
Provider Pardot
Purpose Cookie name associated with services from marketing automation and lead generation platform Pardot. The visitor value is the visitor_id in your Pardot account. This cookie is set for visitors by the Pardot tracking code.
Host(s) .pardot.com, pi.pardot.com, skai.io
Cookie Name pardot, visitor_id*, lpv*
Cookie Expiry Session / 10 Years
Accept
Name
Provider Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
Purpose Cookie by Google used for conversion tracking of Google Ads.
Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
Cookie Name IDE, 1P_JAR, NID, SOCS, CONSENT, AEC, _gcl_au, OTZ, test_cookie
Cookie Expiry Session / 400 Days
Accept
Name
Provider Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, 4 Grand Canal Square, Dublin 2, Ireland
Purpose Cookie by Facebook used for website analytics, ad targeting, and ad measurement.
Privacy Policy https://www.facebook.com/policies/cookies
Cookie Name _fbp,act,c_user,datr,fr,tr,m_pixel_ration,pl,presence,sb,spin,wd,xs
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year

Content from video platforms and social media platforms is blocked by default. If External Media cookies are accepted, access to those contents no longer requires manual consent.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Accept
Name
Provider Wistia
Host(s) .wistia.com
Cookie Name cb_anonymous_id, _sp_ses.2b40, _li_dcdm_c, __hssrc, _gcl_au, _clsk, hubspotutk, _sp_id.2b40, __hssc, __hstc, _uetsid, _uetvid, _gid, _ga, _ga_GQR109DZ3Y, _lc2, fpi, _ex-pricing-cta, _fbp, cb_group_id, cb_user_id, _clck
Cookie Expiry Session / 400 Days
Accept
Name
Provider Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, 4 Grand Canal Square, Dublin 2, Ireland
Purpose Used to unblock Instagram content.
Privacy Policy https://www.instagram.com/legal/privacy/
Host(s) .instagram.com
Cookie Name pigeon_state
Cookie Expiry Session
Accept
Name
Provider Openstreetmap Foundation, St John’s Innovation Centre, Cowley Road, Cambridge CB4 0WS, United Kingdom
Purpose Used to unblock OpenStreetMap content.
Privacy Policy https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Privacy_Policy
Host(s) .openstreetmap.org
Cookie Name _osm_location, _osm_session, _osm_totp_token, _osm_welcome, _pk_id., _pk_ref., _pk_ses., qos_token
Cookie Expiry 1-10 Years
Accept
Name
Provider Twitter International Company, One Cumberland Place, Fenian Street, Dublin 2, D02 AX07, Ireland
Purpose Used to unblock Twitter content.
Privacy Policy https://twitter.com/privacy
Host(s) .twimg.com, .twitter.com
Cookie Name __widgetsettings, local_storage_support_test
Cookie Expiry Unlimited
Accept
Name
Provider Vimeo Inc., 555 West 18th Street, New York, New York 10011, USA
Purpose Used to unblock Vimeo content.
Privacy Policy https://vimeo.com/privacy
Host(s) player.vimeo.com
Cookie Name vuid
Cookie Expiry 2 Years
Accept
Name
Provider Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
Purpose Used to unblock YouTube content.
Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en&gl=en
Host(s) google.com
Cookie Name CONSENT
Cookie Expiry 6 Month

Borlabs Cookie powered by Borlabs Cookie

Privacy Policy Imprint