2026 CPG Marketing Formula #2: Navigating the Shrinking Middle in 2026

For decades, the middle was where CPG brands built empires: mainstream products priced between value and premium, representing 60-70% of category volume. Value and premium were the outliers. The middle was the norm, delivering consistent volume, predictable margins, and broad appeal. That reliable center is now under siege.

But over the last decade, private-label quality has improved, direct-to-consumer brands are capturing premium segments, global competition is intensifying, AI-driven retail operations are enabling competitors to optimize pricing and inventory with unprecedented precision, and shoppers facing economic uncertainty are rethinking what “worth paying more for” even means. The familiar space between value and premium is disappearing, and with it, the comfort zone many brands relied on for steady volume and predictable loyalty.

The squeeze isn’t uniform, and that’s precisely the challenge. In some categories, mainstream SKUs are declining 5-7% annually, while value and premium variants are growing at double digits. Other categories are bifurcating more slowly but just as inevitably. Within each brand portfolio, some products retain pricing power, while others face relentless share erosion.

The middle is eroding faster than most brands’ quarterly planning cycles can address, and static campaigns can’t keep pace with competitive dynamics that shift weekly.

What worked before isn’t working now

Brands can’t defend the middle by repeating the same value propositions at louder volumes. Market dynamics have shifted from gradual evolution to structural disruption that requires fundamentally different capabilities: adaptive systems that prove superiority when competitive context shifts, rescue operations for exposed mainstream SKUs, and edge-portfolio strategies that position brands where demand is actually flowing.

This is the formula for navigating competitive intensity that quarterly campaigns can’t address and for building the infrastructure that turns proving brand value from a periodic marketing message into an always-on operating system.

Current budget realities make this more urgent. According to eMarketer’s US CPG Industry Ad Spending Forecast 2025, CPG digital ad growth is slowing to 6.1%, reaching approximately $52.99 billion, below the national average. Meanwhile, rising input costs, tariffs, and supply chain pressures are forcing CPG brands to cut discretionary spending, meaning every marketing dollar must prove value faster than before.

The tactical approaches that sustained mainstream positioning no longer function at the speed at which markets now move. Annual brand campaigns set value propositions in stone for 12 months when competitive positioning shifts monthly. Quarterly refreshes respond to market changes after the share has already eroded. Product innovation cycles that take 18 months arrive too late to capture bifurcating demand. And measurement systems that report results 60 days after campaigns end can’t guide mid-campaign optimization when share battles happen intra-daily.

These constraints show up everywhere.

Private label launches steal 3-4 points of share before brands even register the threat. Premium challengers build traction through influencer partnerships that traditional measurement never captures. Price gaps widen during promotional periods, and messaging can’t adapt fast enough to contextualize value. New competitive entrants flood retail media with aggressive spend, and established brands can’t pivot budgets mid-quarter to respond.

The gap between market velocity and organizational capability isn’t a minor inconvenience. It’s determining which brands defend their positions and which watch share erode in slow motion while planning next year’s campaign.

Building these capabilities requires a unified cross-functional data infrastructure. Marketing, Sales, and Supply Chain teams must work from shared intelligence rather than siloed dashboards. When competitive threats emerge, response speed depends on whether teams can access integrated shelf data, sales velocity, and inventory signals simultaneously. Organizations still operating with disconnected data systems will struggle to build the capabilities that market speed now demands.

Where does your organization stand?

Before building new systems, assess where your organization actually stands.

Quick gut check: How fast can you actually prove value when it matters?

1. We react to share loss after it’s already happened
2. We know what’s broken, but can’t move fast enough to fix it
3. We’re nimble in some areas, still slow in others
4. We spot threats early and respond in days, not quarters

Now let’s get specific. Use these 15 questions to identify which capabilities require immediate attention. Where you answer ‘no’ or hesitate, you’ve identified capability gaps actively costing share.

Mainstream SKU risk identification:

• Do you know which SKUs are at serious risk of erosion right now?
• Can you quantify exposure: how many mainstream products show declining unit velocity, widening price gaps versus competitors, or deteriorating review scores?
• When share declines, can you identify the cause (price, quality perception, availability, competitive launch) within a week?

Rescue sprint capability:

• Can you launch rescue sprints in under 30 days when a mainstream SKU shows distress signals?
• Do you have cross-functional strike teams (Marketing, R&D, Sales) with authority to move fast?
• Or do approval processes, budget locks, and organizational friction stretch intervention timelines to quarters?

Edge variant testing:

• Are you systematically testing edge variants (value and premium)?
• How many value/premium tests are in-market right now?
• Can you measure whether they’re truly incremental or just cannibalizing core SKUs?
• When tests succeed, how quickly can you scale: weeks or quarters?

Adaptive creative systems:

• Can your creative respond when the competitive context shifts significantly?
• When price gaps widen, do your campaigns emphasize quality or performance differences?
• When new competitors enter, does messaging adjust to reinforce superiority?
• Or do campaigns stay static for their full flight regardless of competitive shifts?

Cross-channel measurement and optimization:

• Can you compare cost-per-conversion across retail media, search, and social using a unified measurement framework?
• Do you optimize spend weekly across channels based on performance data?
• Or do budgets stay locked until quarterly reviews, even when data shows clear reallocation opportunities?

Core capabilities for proving value when conditions change

The following capabilities represent the operational infrastructure that defending the middle now requires. These aren’t theoretical best practices. They’re essential systems for operating in markets where competitive dynamics outpace quarterly planning cycles.

However, most CPG organizations face significant talent and structural gaps that complicate their capability-building efforts. Marketing teams may lack the technical expertise to interpret unified commerce data. Data analytics resources are often concentrated in Finance rather than distributed across commercial functions. Cross-functional collaboration muscles remain underdeveloped after years of siloed operation. Addressing these variances through training, strategic hires, or organizational redesign becomes a prerequisite for the capabilities outlined below.

Save at-risk products faster

When mainstream products show distress signals, most organizations respond too slowly.

By the time declining velocity triggers formal reviews, new competitors have established position and private label has stolen share that won’t come back easily. Building this capability means establishing weekly monitoring of early warning signals (price gaps widening, review scores dropping, availability declining, new competitors launching), then forming cross-functional strike teams that run 2-4 week sprints testing new value proofs in targeted channels.

Connected data systems that surface early warning signals, clear success criteria for deciding whether to scale, iterate, or exit, and organizational structures that enable fast decisions rather than analysis paralysis all become essential.

Unified commerce media platforms that integrate shelf intelligence with campaign activation enable these rescue sprints by connecting competitive context directly to creative deployment across retail media, search, and social channels. The rise of diversified retail media networks, where major retailers now operate sophisticated advertising platforms, makes this integration even more critical. Brands must prove value not just on Amazon, but across Walmart Connect, Target Roundel, Kroger Precision Marketing, and dozens of other retail media networks, each with unique inventory signals and shopper behaviors. Rescue sprints that can activate across this fragmented landscape deliver measurably better outcomes than single-channel interventions.

Progress indicators include saving a meaningful portion of exposed mainstream SKUs through targeted interventions rather than watching a gradual decline, building muscle for fast decisions, and intervention cycles that take weeks rather than quarters. This approach requires connected data and works best in categories with baseline brand equity still intact.

Test value and premium variants

As the middle erodes, defending mainstream positions exclusively becomes insufficient.

Building this capability means systematically testing value and premium variants rather than betting everything on current SKUs. This involves using consumer segmentation to spot bifurcation patterns, developing variants that authentically extend brand strengths (stripping non-essentials for value plays, adding benefits for premium positioning), and validating P&L through incrementality testing that separates real opportunities from expensive distractions.

While portfolio development itself requires broader organizational capabilities, testing and validating new variants at speed benefits significantly from unified measurement across retail media, search, and social channels that can track incremental impact.

Progress indicators include portfolio mix shifting toward edges fast enough to offset mainstream losses, innovation cycles that used to take 18 months happening in quarters, and new variants that earn their place through measured incrementality rather than hopeful projections. This demands R&D flexibility and ruthless focus on where your brand has permission to play.

Update messaging as conditions change

Static campaigns can’t prove superiority when competitive dynamics shift constantly and shoppers evaluate alternatives across multiple touchpoints.

Building this capability means integrating digital shelf data with creative systems to trigger updates when context changes significantly: when price gaps widen materially, emphasize ingredient or performance proofs; when new competitors gain meaningful traction, reinforce unique benefits; when economic indicators shift, adjust value framing accordingly.

This doesn’t require millisecond automation. It requires having the infrastructure to refresh creative weekly or bi-weekly based on competitive intelligence, and the organizational agility to deploy those updates across search, social, and retail media without waiting for quarterly campaign cycles.

Platforms that connect shelf intelligence to campaign optimization across 200+ retail endpoints enable this contextualization, allowing teams to respond to competitive shifts in days or weeks rather than quarters. The goal is messaging that proves value when it matters most, deployed at the speed competitive dynamics demand.

Progress indicators include conversion rates improving specifically when competitive pressure intensifies (not just overall averages), creative teams shifting from quarterly campaign production to continuous optimization cycles, and marketing spend efficiency increasing without additional budget.

This needs a connected data infrastructure, but can start effectively in high-volume channels before expanding.

How to start

Building systems that prove value as conditions change requires systematic effort across multiple domains: rescue sprint capabilities, edge-portfolio strategies, and dynamic contextualization. While each organization’s journey differs based on current market position, portfolio exposure, and technical infrastructure, the following principles apply universally.

Start with assessment. Use the 15 questions above to diagnose the current state and identify the highest-priority gaps. Focus on the areas where a lack of responsive systems is actively costing share or margin today. If multiple mainstream SKUs are already declining, rescue sprint capabilities become urgent. If the middle is stable but showing early erosion signals, contextualization infrastructure may be the priority.

Recognize the convergence reshaping commerce media infrastructure. Three once-separate channels are merging into an integrated ecosystem: retail media network (RMN) data now powers connected TV attribution, programmatic retail media is emerging as standard practice for audience targeting beyond retailer properties, and full-funnel commerce media, where awareness, consideration, and conversion campaigns operate from unified measurement, is becoming the norm rather than the exception. Organizations building marketing systems that respond to changing conditions must account for this convergence. The infrastructure decisions you make today should enable cross-channel orchestration, not reinforce channel silos that the market is already abandoning.

Prioritize based on portfolio risk. Don’t attempt to build all three capabilities simultaneously unless multiple SKUs are in immediate danger. For most organizations, starting with dynamic contextualization delivers the fastest ROI while building the data infrastructure that enables rescue sprints later. Organizations with significant portfolio exposure may need to move faster across all three.

Secure cross-functional alignment. This transformation requires coordination across Marketing, R&D, Sales, and Finance. Brand managers need to partner with innovation teams on edge variants. Marketing needs Finance backing to reallocate budgets based on performance data. Sales needs advanced warning about potential SKU rationalization. CMO leadership is typically essential for orchestrating these relationships.

Start with one at-risk SKU or category as a proof-of-concept. Run a rescue sprint or test adaptive messaging on a single channel. Prove ROI. Scale the approach. But move quickly. Waiting for perfect data or ideal conditions means watching share erode while planning.

Measure what matters. Track the specific indicators outlined for each capability. Don’t just measure campaign performance. Measure decision velocity, intervention success rates, and portfolio mix evolution. Celebrate wins. Course-correct when progress stalls.

Plan for 6-12 months. Building these systems is faster than full transformation initiatives but still requires sustained commitment. Rescue sprints can show results in quarters, but full infrastructure takes a year. Set realistic timelines and maintain focus even when competing priorities emerge.

Conclusion: Building the systems that market speed demands

The organizations investing in these capabilities now are positioning themselves to defend viable mainstream positions while capturing bifurcating demand at the edges.

With traditional advertising declining and digital budgets under pressure, systems that prove value as competitive context shifts have become not just a best practice, but a survival requirement.

This infrastructure is both strategically sound and commercially essential. The question for CPG marketers: Are you building these capabilities fast enough to matter?

Skai’s Retail Media solutions enable marketers to plan, activate, and measure campaigns across 200+ retailers (including Amazon, Walmart, Target, and Instacart) as part of a broader commerce media strategy. AI-powered pacing, product intelligence, and keyword tools help teams meet shoppers across the journey and tie spend to sales with confidence.

Beyond multi-channel campaign management, Skai addresses the unified data layer challenge that most CPG organizations struggle to solve internally. By connecting shelf signals, sales velocity, competitive intelligence, and campaign performance into a single view, Skai eliminates the cross-organizational visibility gaps that slow decision-making and prevent adaptive response. When Marketing, Sales, and Analytics teams work from shared real-time intelligence rather than fragmented reports, the capabilities outlined in this framework (rescue sprints, adaptive messaging, edge-portfolio testing) become operationally feasible rather than aspirational.

When proving value at market speed determines whether mainstream SKUs survive, a unified infrastructure that connects shelf signals to creative optimization becomes essential, not optional.

See how Skai helps leading CPG brands prove value as conditions change. Schedule a quick demo.

---

Frequently Asked Questions