• DE&I Commitment
  • Careers
  • Locations
  • Book a Meeting
    Book a Meeting
  • Company
    Learn a little more about us, our values, and our team
    Our Values
    We don't just talk the talk; we live by our core values
    About Us
    Empowering brands to realize their potential with data, insights, and technology
    Leadership
    Meet our leadership team
    Secure Data Architecture
    Our promise of data security and privacy. We keep your data safe from publishers, competitors and bad actors
    Corporate Social Responsibility
    We are committed to making a positive impact on our communities and our planet
  • Platform
    Plan, manage, optimize, and measure your campaigns with our omnichannel platform
    Our Platform
    A platform that connects all walled garden media
    Connected Media
    Create and manage campaigns across search, social, retail media and apps, in one platform
    Connected Data
    Make data-driven decisions as you plan and strategize
    See the industries we serve
    Learn how our customizable solutions can help with your unique needs
    Explore our partner integrations
    See the media, retailer, and data partners we work with
  • Clients
  • News and Events
    Check out recent announcements and see what we’re up to
    News
    Check out our recent media coverage
    Events
    Join us for our next conference or webinar
    Quarterly Trends Webinar
    Get the latest insights on digital marketing campaign performance for Q4 2022
    Retail Media for Grocery Webinar
    Join us to dig into trends and challenges shaping the industry in 2023
  • Resources
    From new releases, to industry trends and best practices, Skai has you covered
    Blog
    Read the latest insights and thought leadership from our industry experts
    Capabilities
    Take your campaigns to the next level by enhancing your platform capabilities
    Research
    Explore our reports and whitepapers so you can keep up on the latest industry trends
    Subscribe
    Sign up to get the latest updates straight to your inbox
    Quarterly Trends Report
    Learn digital advertising campaign performance trends from Q3 2022
Back to Blog

What’s Going to Happen with Multi-Touch Attribution in a Cookieless World?

Moti Radomski, VP, Product @ Skai™

February  18, 2021

With new limitations on consumer data privacy, advertisers are going to need to adapt. What is the role of attribution in a cookieless world? 

Well, my last post created a bit of a stir. The Post-Attribution Era Has Begun: How to Transition Your Org to Cookieless Marketing Measurement was meant to help marketers who see the writing on the wall about how upcoming data tracking changes—namely from Apple (iOS14) and Google (Chrome)—are signaling the end of for multi-touch attribution (MTA). 

I received some feedback about that post from marketers who are still hoping attribution in a cookieless world can still be viable. This is completely understandable—given the amount of time, effort, and investments in MTA, this transition isn’t insignificant and will certainly be incredibly difficult to pull off for most orgs. 

But, even the most fervent MTA defenders know that when Apple and Google finally flip the data privacy switch there will be some serious issues with the approach. In another post, Marketing Measurement Cannot Be Reliant on Individual Customer Journeys: Incrementality is the Fix, I offer the same conversation points I’ve had with scores of marketers over the past year:

“What if I was to tell you less than 30% of the results you measure are correct? Are you still going to hold on to your customer journey-based measurement system? 

What about less than 20%?

Less than 10%?

Less than 5%? 

So, marketers. I ask you: How flawed are you willing to accept your measurement approach?”

It stands to reason that some marketers will simply ignore the issues and maintain the status quo, enabling MTA to continue within their organizations. I would offer that this is like navigating with a faulty compass—and that they almost certainly end up optimizing AWAY from campaign elements that are creating value and optimize TOWARD campaign elements that aren’t working. 

But, for those of you who are going to take the hard road ahead away from MTA as your primary measurement methodology, you may still wonder:

Does multi-touch attribution in a cookieless world still hold value?

It does. 

Sort of. 

Let me explain.

Rewinding a decade to the end of Last Click and the beginning of the MTA Era

Around 2007, marketers began to realize that the standard way of measuring digital advertising was flawed. Most systems were attributing the entire value of a conversion to whatever the “last ad click” was determined to be, called Last Click. 

Take for example the following [fictitious] user purchase path:

attribution in a cookieless world

In the Last Click approach, that last Google Search Ad receives 100% of the $150 sale. Last Click wasn’t really an agreed-upon way to measure digital advertising, it was just the default way that the various ad buying technology worked. 

Once the flaws of Last Click were pointed out, every marketer at the time instantly realized this was not very accurate. After all, the email, the YouTube ad, the Facebook ad, and even the organic search link (SEO programs cost money too) should receive some credit. It was like a light bulb went off around the industry. 

MTA was the solution.

Multi-touch attribution helped marketers spread the value of the tracked ad exposures to a converting user. Using algorithmic weighting, the $150 conversion value in our example was spread across the exposures to better reflect the combination of ad impressions and clicks that worked together to drive the sale. For example, the Facebook ad might be credited $10 of the sale. The YouTube video, $25. And so on. That may not sound like a big deal, but if you’re a giant retailer and getting thousands of orders a day, those “fractional” attributed dollars add up, providing a more complete understanding of the contribution of every channel in the media mix. 

MTA was a major upgrade to the Last Click! That’s undeniable. I was a huge fan of MTA at the time. It finally got us closer to truly understanding the efficacy of our campaigns. 

Remember, this was around the time when the vast majority of web browsing activity happened on a desktop. Tracking users was fairly easy and every marketing org jumped on the MTA bandwagon.

But then, around the same time that MTA was taking off…the world changed. In 2007, the iPhone launched. Since then, the proliferation of devices (smartphones, tablets, smart TVs, voice assistants, gaming consoles, etc.) has fragmented a user’s browsing activity to the point where it’s become almost impossible to track every ad exposure back to a single user.

Without being able to connect the dots of the consumer journey, the effectiveness of MTA has been degrading. “MTA is expensive and ‘creates more questions than it answers,’ said Alyssa Perry, senior director of marketing of FabFitFu”, in the 2019 AdExchanger article, As Marketers Tire Of Last-Click And MTA, Incrementality Testing Finds Its Niche.

There have been attempts to create a “unified view of the customer” over the last decade to preserve MTA’s status as the primary marketing measurement approach. While there have been many leaks in the system, MTA has been able to remain viable. 

However, with the upcoming limitations to consumer data—aka “the final nail in the coffin”—MTA is just not going to work as it did anymore.

Attribution in a cookieless world: MTA will still be valuable within closed ecosystems 

While MTA across channels will become ineffective, multi-touch attribution will still have value for day-to-day optimization within the closed ecosystems of the biggest publishers such as Google, Facebook, Amazon, and others. These players have logged-in users across their devices and can track multiple interactions between a brand and its customers. 

So, for example, Google advertising practitioners analyzing their media mix on Google can use Google attribution metrics to do so. Google Search attribution can help determine which combination of keywords are often used to drive users to convert. This can be helpful to optimize keywords, match types, ad copy, ad formats, etc. The same can happen on Facebook for Facebook marketers, on Amazon for Amazon marketers, and in any closed ecosystem that can maintain a unified view of each user. 

attribution in a cookieless worldThe good news here is that the advertising world is already moving this way ads digital investments are moving to those giant publishers—nearly 2/3rds of all digital ad spending is being spent just with Google, Facebook, and Amazon.  Remember, the tracking issues in which the industry impacts measurement, but also ad targeting, personalization, and other advanced tactics marketers have enjoyed over the last decade. 

CAVEAT #1 – Even with the strong tracking that these publishers can maintain with logged-in users, MTA is directional. For example, Google can see the 5 ad exposures to a single user, but it might have been an email, a TV commercial, or some external marketing interaction that influenced a conversion. But, for optimizing bids/budgets/ads, a closed ecosystem’s MTA can be helpful for channel practitioners.

CAVEAT #2 – This information won’t be helpful to determine budget allocation between channels, just intra-channel optimizations. A new measurement approach will be needed to determine cross-channel media-mix effectiveness.

Goodbye MTA, hello Incrementality

Regardless of how hard this transition will be, multi-touch attribution in a cookieless world won’t be a sustainable strategy pretty soon. So, some channel practitioners will still be able to tap into some MTA to optimize their programs, but as the primary/default measurement methodology, multi-touch attribution has had its day. 

What is the right approach? Well, Incrementality is certainly at the top of marketer conversations these days. 

Why? Because Incrementality:

  • Is a cookieless measurement solution
  • Can determine if ad elements had any incremental value to a conversion
  • Is able to answer questions MTA could never answer such as the impact of offline marketing on online sales—and vice versa

Incrementality is a bit different than MTA and simply can’t be swapped out like using a new email tool. It will require more planning and discipline. I will be writing more about that next month. 

For more information on Skai’s Incrementality testing platform, Impact Navigator, please schedule a quick demo. Seeing this tool will help to illuminate how Incrementality works and how you will be able to replace MTA with a much more accurate and flexible measurement approach.

Book a Meeting of Impact Navigator

Related Posts

  • The Annual Skai Hackathon Fosters Team-Building and Innovation
    Read More
  • How Skai Takes the Growing Pains Out of the Client Onboarding Process
    Read More
  • [WATCH] Reinvent Your Marketing Strategy for the Next Normal
    Read More
  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – April 2021
    Read More
  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – September 2021
    Read More
  • Monthly Paid Media Spend Snapshot – August 2021
    Read More
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share via Email
  • Copy Link
    Copied!
Tags: Amazon, Apps, Data, Data & Insights, Ecommerce, Facebook, Google, Incrementality, Local, Measure, Optimize, Search, Social, Target, xTLx

Subscribe to Updates

Media that matters.
Marketing that works.
© 2023 Kenshoo, Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy. Cookie Policy. Recruitment Privacy Policy.
  • Connected Data
    • Market Intelligence
    • Our Approach
    • By Need
    • By Solution
  • Connected Strategy
    • Dynamic Marketing Mix
    • Budget Forecasting
    • Strategic Consulting
  • Connected Media
    • Overview
    • Retail Media
    • Paid Search
    • Paid Social
    • App Marketing
    • Auditing
    • Expert Services
  • Measurement
    • Incrementality
    • Experiments
    • Cross-Channel Attribution
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Glossary
    • Case Studies
    • Training & Enablement
    • Developer Hub
Privacy Preference

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential, while others help us to improve this website and your experience.

Privacy Preference

Save All

Save

Accept Only Essential Cookies

Manage Cookie Preferences

Cookie Details Privacy Policy Imprint

Privacy Preference

Here you will find an overview of all cookies used. You can give your consent to whole categories or display further information and select certain cookies.

Save All Save Accept Only Essential Cookies

Back

Privacy Preference

Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Name
Provider Owner of this website, Imprint
Purpose Saves the visitors preferences selected in the Cookie Box of Borlabs Cookie.
Host(s) .skai.io, skai.io
Cookie Name borlabs-cookie
Cookie Expiry 1 Year
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Purpose This cookie stores selections made by the user in the Accessibe tool in order to maintain those settings on future visits. These cookies help us make our website compliant with our obligations under US law.
Privacy Policy https://accessibe.com/privacy-policy
Cookie Name acsbState, acsbReset
Cookie Expiry n/a
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Host(s) skai.io
Cookie Name wordpress_sec_,wordpress_test_cookie,wp-postpass_*, wordpresspass_*, wordpressuser_*
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year

We use these cookies to enhance functionality and allow for personalisation, such as live chats, videos and the use of social media.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Accept
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Host(s) .chilipiper.com, skai.chilipiper.com
Cookie Name fs_uid, CHILI_PIPER_CLUSTER, guest-session, _sp_ses*, _sp_id*
Cookie Expiry Session / 2 Years
Accept
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Host(s) .comeet.co, www.comeet.co
Cookie Name visid_incap_, nlbi_#######, incap_ses_, referrer22_00a, incap_ses_1364_2167377
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year
Accept
Name
Provider Owner of this website
Host(s) skai.io
Cookie Name moduleFormPardotDownload
Cookie Expiry 30 days

Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us to understand how our visitors use our website.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Accept
Name
Provider Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
Purpose Cookie by Google used for website analytics. Generates statistical data on how the visitor uses the website.
Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
Cookie Name _ga,_ga_*,_gat,_gat_*,_gid
Cookie Expiry 2 Months
Accept
Name
Provider Hotjar Ltd., Dragonara Business Centre, 5th Floor, Dragonara Road, Paceville St Julian's STJ 3141 Malta
Purpose Hotjar is an user behavior analytic tool by Hotjar Ltd.. We use Hotjar to understand how users interact with our website.
Privacy Policy https://www.hotjar.com/legal/policies/privacy/
Host(s) *.hotjar.com
Cookie Name _hjClosedSurveyInvites, _hjDonePolls, _hjMinimizedPolls, _hjDoneTestersWidgets, _hjIncludedInSample, _hjShownFeedbackMessage, _hjid, _hjRecordingLastActivity, hjTLDTest, _hjUserAttributesHash, _hjCachedUserAttributes, _hjLocalStorageTest, _hjptid, _hjSessionUser_2229986, _hjIncludedInPageviewSample, _hjIncludedInSessionSample, _hjAbsoluteSessionInProgress, _hjFirstSeen
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year

Marketing cookies are used by third-party advertisers or publishers to display personalized ads. They do this by tracking visitors across websites.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Accept
Name
Provider Linkedin
Cookie Name lidc, li_gc, lang, AnalyticsSyncHistory, UserMatchHistory, li_sugr, bcookie, TDCPM, TDID, bscookie, ln_or
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year
Accept
Name
Provider Skai
Accept
Name
Provider 6sense
Cookie Name _gd_session, _an_uid, _gd_visitor, _gd_svisitor, 6suuid
Cookie Expiry Session / 400 Days
Accept
Name
Provider Pardot
Purpose Cookie name associated with services from marketing automation and lead generation platform Pardot. The visitor value is the visitor_id in your Pardot account. This cookie is set for visitors by the Pardot tracking code.
Host(s) .pardot.com, pi.pardot.com, skai.io
Cookie Name pardot, visitor_id*, lpv*
Cookie Expiry Session / 10 Years
Accept
Name
Provider Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
Purpose Cookie by Google used for conversion tracking of Google Ads.
Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
Cookie Name IDE, 1P_JAR, NID, SOCS, CONSENT, AEC, _gcl_au, OTZ, test_cookie
Cookie Expiry Session / 400 Days
Accept
Name
Provider Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, 4 Grand Canal Square, Dublin 2, Ireland
Purpose Cookie by Facebook used for website analytics, ad targeting, and ad measurement.
Privacy Policy https://www.facebook.com/policies/cookies
Cookie Name _fbp,act,c_user,datr,fr,tr,m_pixel_ration,pl,presence,sb,spin,wd,xs
Cookie Expiry Session / 1 Year

Content from video platforms and social media platforms is blocked by default. If External Media cookies are accepted, access to those contents no longer requires manual consent.

Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

Accept
Name
Provider Wistia
Host(s) .wistia.com
Cookie Name cb_anonymous_id, _sp_ses.2b40, _li_dcdm_c, __hssrc, _gcl_au, _clsk, hubspotutk, _sp_id.2b40, __hssc, __hstc, _uetsid, _uetvid, _gid, _ga, _ga_GQR109DZ3Y, _lc2, fpi, _ex-pricing-cta, _fbp, cb_group_id, cb_user_id, _clck
Cookie Expiry Session / 400 Days
Accept
Name
Provider Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, 4 Grand Canal Square, Dublin 2, Ireland
Purpose Used to unblock Instagram content.
Privacy Policy https://www.instagram.com/legal/privacy/
Host(s) .instagram.com
Cookie Name pigeon_state
Cookie Expiry Session
Accept
Name
Provider Openstreetmap Foundation, St John’s Innovation Centre, Cowley Road, Cambridge CB4 0WS, United Kingdom
Purpose Used to unblock OpenStreetMap content.
Privacy Policy https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Privacy_Policy
Host(s) .openstreetmap.org
Cookie Name _osm_location, _osm_session, _osm_totp_token, _osm_welcome, _pk_id., _pk_ref., _pk_ses., qos_token
Cookie Expiry 1-10 Years
Accept
Name
Provider Twitter International Company, One Cumberland Place, Fenian Street, Dublin 2, D02 AX07, Ireland
Purpose Used to unblock Twitter content.
Privacy Policy https://twitter.com/privacy
Host(s) .twimg.com, .twitter.com
Cookie Name __widgetsettings, local_storage_support_test
Cookie Expiry Unlimited
Accept
Name
Provider Vimeo Inc., 555 West 18th Street, New York, New York 10011, USA
Purpose Used to unblock Vimeo content.
Privacy Policy https://vimeo.com/privacy
Host(s) player.vimeo.com
Cookie Name vuid
Cookie Expiry 2 Years
Accept
Name
Provider Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
Purpose Used to unblock YouTube content.
Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en&gl=en
Host(s) google.com
Cookie Name CONSENT
Cookie Expiry 6 Month

Borlabs Cookie powered by Borlabs Cookie

Privacy Policy Imprint