• DE&I Commitment
  • Careers
  • SIGN IN
  • Book a Meeting
    Book a Meeting
  • Company
    Learn a little more about us, our values, and our team
    Our Values
    We don't just talk the talk; we live by our core values
    About Us
    Empowering brands to realize their potential with data, insights, and technology
    Leadership
    Meet our leadership team
    Secure Data Architecture
    Our promise of data security and privacy. We keep your data safe from publishers, competitors and bad actors
    Corporate Social Responsibility
    We are committed to making a positive impact on our communities and our planet
  • Platform
    Plan, manage, optimize, and measure your campaigns with our omnichannel platform
    Omnichannel Advertising
    A platform that connects all walled garden media for more effective campaigns
    Data Connectivity
    Make data-driven decisions as you plan and strategize
    AI-Powered Capabilities
    Take your campaigns to the next level by leveraging proprietary AI-based technology
    See the industries we serve
    Learn how our customizable solutions can help with your unique needs
    Explore our partner integrations
    See the media, retailer, and data partners we work with
  • Case Studies
  • News and Events
    Check out recent announcements and see what we’re up to
    Newsroom
    Check out our recent media mentions and announcements
    Events
    Join us for our next conference or webinar
    Omnichannel platform launch
    Read the press release to see how we're helping marketers win the walled gardens
    AI Breakthrough Award
    Skai Named "Best AI-based Solution for Advertising" in 6th Annual Artificial Intelligence Breakthrough Awards Program
  • Resources
    From new releases, to industry trends and best practices, Skai has you covered
    The Breakthrough
    Read the latest blog posts and thought leadership from Skai and other industry experts
    Skai Research
    Explore our studies, whitepapers and quarterly trends reports so you can stay up to date
    Quarterly Trends Hub
    Dive into the latest market insights, industry trends, and predictive analysis
    Holiday Hub 2023
    Your go-to source for holiday marketing tips, tricks, and best practices
Back to Blog

Life Without Multi-Touch Attribution: How Your Marketing Measurement Program Will Change Under Incrementality

Moti Radomski, VP, Product @ Skai

April  19, 2021

Marketers will first embrace incrementality for its cookieless nature but will come to find out that its benefits dramatically exceed even the best results of multi-touch attribution in their marketing measurement program.

As I wrote in a previous post, Marketing Measurement Cannot Be Reliant on Individual Customer Journeys: Incrementality is the Fix, upcoming limitations to third-party cookies are going to severely limit the way that marketers will be able to target consumers, personalize ads, measure effectiveness, optimize program performance, and a slew of other tactics that this industry has taken for granted in the past. 

This isn’t a “maybe this will happen” prediction. Google is committed to killing third-party cookies. They’ve already stated that it’s not just about how Chrome collects data. Their plan is to block any industry or vendor attempts to bypass their policies with other ID programs.

When it comes to a marketing measurement program specifically—the key ingredient to performance optimization—legacy models such as multi-touch attribution (MTA) will need to be replaced by cookieless solutions like incrementality. To learn more about this methodology, check out The Single, Most Important Difference Between Incrementality and Multi-Touch Attribution (MTA). 

Making such a big transition from multi-touch attribution—something most marketers know a lot about—and into incrementality—something most marketers know very little about—can be a painful shift. Although I laid out a change management plan to help those of your moving into incrementality, today, I’m going to turn the page on MTA and help you better understand what life will be like under incrementality. 

MTA = lagging data vs Incrementality = leading insights

Under multi-touch attribution, the way marketers plan and buy media really doesn’t change much. In a perfect world, MTA solutions track all of the brand touchpoints with individual users across channels in order to deliver a unified view of the customer. Going back to an example that I’ve shared multiple times, the following is a basic user path to conversion as they interact with multiple marketing exposures over a week before finally converting on the website:

Because each channel can only track its individual exposures, channel practitioners can only measure the contribution of their channel to conversion. So, in this marketing measurement program example, the Facebook practitioner would see in their platform that a Wednesday ad click created Saturday’s sale, a YouTube marketer would see that a Tuesday video exposure drove the sale, and an email marketer would think that their Monday blast was what caused the sale.

Multi-touch attribution was supposed to solve this by sitting on top of all channels, provide a unified view, and then apply smart math to determine how much of the $150 sale should be attributed to each exposure—i.e. the Facebook ad might receive $20 in credit, the YouTube ad $10, and the email $25, and so on. 

The glaring problem here, of course, is that it’s virtually impossible to track EVERY marketing exposure. What about offline media such as TV, radio, print, billboards, etc? Or other digital ads that aren’t trackable? Of course, if there were actually 10 exposures but the MTA system only tracks 5, then the math is absolutely flawed. And more importantly, what if an ad exposure had zero incremental value in driving a sale? MTA will try to give credit where no credit is due.

Champions of MTA argue that the insights are directional, but that’s just a nice way to say it’s flawed. And, with the third-party cookies going away, it will be even harder to provide a unified view and that flawed approach will be rendered virtually invalid (except in a few specific use cases).

Champions of MTA argue that the insights are directional, but that’s just a nice way to say it’s flawed.

On the other side, incrementality relies on a test and learn approach. Like the science experiments that we all learned in middle school, marketers use Test and Control groups to expose marketing campaign elements (channel, message, ad, etc.) to one group and not the other. By comparing the results, they can better understand the incremental value that the campaign element has on performance. 

The key benefit here is that because incrementality compares the Test and Control groups, all of the nuances and subtleties of individual exposure tracking that can be so easily missed by multi-touch attribution are negated and the causal impact of your media investments is revealed. Incrementality simply says, “Your business is X% bigger (or not) because the tested tactic(s) was present .”  It doesn’t attempt to explain everything going on with your programs, just gives a clear result of whatever you have decided to test. 

And so, here we have the main functional difference of MTA vs Incrementality approaches to marketing measurement: 

  • Like a rearview mirror, multi-touch attribution is a passive, lagging dataset that marketers use to understand past campaigns in order to better plan subsequent programs
  • Like a front windshield, incrementality is a premediated, leading dataset that marketers use to answer burning questions about program efficacy in order to improve current programs

Life under incrementality: a deeper connection between media and measurement 

A test and learn marketing measurement approach such as incrementality will require a more rigorous process than MTA. Practitioners need to plan out their tests, sort them by priority, execute those tests, and analyze the results. Then, they can make smarter, data-driven decisions on budget allocation, messaging creative, bids, and other choices that can help to improve the efficacy of their programs before they begin. 

Incrementality tests can illuminate key gaps in the way marketers understand their activity before the campaign runs. That way, marketers can start with an optimized campaign and then improve results even higher as it runs with in-flight optimization.

So, yes, an honest assessment here is that incrementality will take more time and effort than MTA.  

But, here’s the good part and why it’s worth it…

Because incrementality tests need to be planned out methodically, there’s a level of premeditated insight gathering that in essence forces marketers to have a deeper connection between their media and their measurement. You have to think more intentionally about what you want to measure and how best to run those tests in order to get the insights you need. 

If anything, MTA facilitated a bit of laziness on our part as marketers. With incrementality, marketers will have a closer link to the two sides—media & measurement—which most might agree is the ideal state of things. 

Plan your experiments, identify your most burning measurement questions, then test them 

What are some of the questions worth testing with incrementality? 

Here are some of the most popular, burning questions we’ve heard from marketers that they want incrementality tests to answer:

  • Does this channel drive incremental value or would these conversions have happened anyway?
  • What is the impact of one channel on another? If I spend more in one channel, does it help/assist another?
  • What is the optimal level of investment for a specific channel? Are we spending too much or too little?
  • What is the effect of upper-level tactics on lower-funnel activity?
  • How does my offline media assist my online media performance? And vice-versa?
  • Are my promotions and sales worth the discount I’m offering or am I just leaving money on the table?

These are questions that MTA just never was able to answer consistently. And, if it did, the known flaws of that approach can bring up questions of accuracy. Not having confidence in your measurement solution might be even worse than having no measurement solution at all. 

Worried that your marketing measurement program will be disrupted?

The worst thing you can do right now is to wait. 

The end of the third-party cookies is imminent. Skai’s Impact Navigator is an incrementality testing platform that can serve as the technical foundation for your cookieless measurement program. For all of the power of incrementality experiments and measurement, historically, execution has been incredibly resource-intensive. Impact Navigator is a service platform that enables marketers and businesses to measure the incremental impact of advertising tactics on their on and offline business metrics. 

To learn more about incrementality, and to see Impact Navigator for yourself, please contact us to schedule a brief demo.

Even if you’re not ready yet to switch, it’s a good idea to see what’s available so you can start thinking about how you’ll handle the coming changes to MTA and make the most informed decision down the road.

Book a Meeting of Skai

Related Posts

  • Online/Offline Marketing Measurement Isn’t As Impossible As It Once Was
    Read More
  • Marketing Measurement Cannot Be Reliant on Individual Customer Journeys: Incrementality is the Fix
    Read More
  • What’s Your Marketing Measurement Plan Against These 4 Data Deprecation Trends?
    Read More
  • Test and Learn Marketing Can Guide Your Way Through Even the Toughest Market Conditions
    Read More
  • The 4 Ingredients of a Best-in-Class Incrementality Measurement Practice
    Read More
  • Putting Incrementality Measurement Into Action: How to Figure Out What to Test
    Read More
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share via Email
  • Copy Link
    Copied!
Tags: Data, Data & Insights, Facebook, Google, Incrementality, Measure, Optimize, Retail Media, xTLx

    Subscribe to Updates

    Media that matters.
    Marketing that works.
    © 2023 Kenshoo, Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
    Privacy Policy. Cookie Policy. Recruitment Privacy Policy.
    • Omnichannel Strategy
      • Skai HQ
      • Dynamic Marketing Mix
      • Budget Forecasting
      • Strategic Consulting
    • Walled Garden Advertising
      • Overview
      • Retail Media
      • Paid Search
      • Paid Social
      • App Marketing
      • Auditing
      • Expert Services
    • Marketing Measurement
      • Incrementality
      • Experiments
      • Cross-Channel Attribution
    • Resources
      • Blog
      • Glossary
      • Case Studies
      • Capabilities
      • Quarterly Trends Hub
      • Training & Enablement
      • Developer Hub
    Privacy Preference

    We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential, while others help us to improve this website and your experience.

    Privacy Preference

    Save All

    Save

    Accept Only Essential Cookies

    Manage Cookie Preferences

    Cookie Details Privacy Policy Imprint

    Privacy Preference

    Here you will find an overview of all cookies used. You can give your consent to whole categories or display further information and select certain cookies.

    Save All Save Accept Only Essential Cookies

    Back

    Privacy Preference

    Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.

    Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website, Imprint
    PurposeSaves the visitors preferences selected in the Cookie Box of Borlabs Cookie.
    Host(s).skai.io, skai.io
    Cookie Nameborlabs-cookie
    Cookie Expiry1 Year
    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website
    Host(s)skai.io
    Cookie Namewordpress_sec_,wordpress_test_cookie,wp-postpass_*, wordpresspass_*, wordpressuser_*
    Cookie ExpirySession / 1 Year
    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website
    PurposeThis cookie stores selections made by the user in the Accessibe tool in order to maintain those settings on future visits. These cookies help us make our website compliant with our obligations under US law.
    Privacy Policy https://accessibe.com/privacy-policy
    Cookie NameacsbState, acsbReset
    Cookie Expiryn/a

    We use these cookies to enhance functionality and allow for personalisation, such as live chats, videos and the use of social media.

    Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

    Accept
    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website
    Host(s).comeet.co, www.comeet.co
    Cookie Namevisid_incap_, nlbi_#######, incap_ses_, referrer22_00a, incap_ses_1364_2167377
    Cookie ExpirySession / 1 Year
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website
    Host(s).chilipiper.com, skai.chilipiper.com
    Cookie Namefs_uid, CHILI_PIPER_CLUSTER, guest-session, _sp_ses*, _sp_id*
    Cookie ExpirySession / 2 Years
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website
    Host(s)skai.io
    Cookie NamemoduleFormPardotDownload
    Cookie Expiry30 days

    Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us to understand how our visitors use our website.

    Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

    Accept
    Name
    ProviderGoogle Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
    PurposeCookie by Google used for website analytics. Generates statistical data on how the visitor uses the website.
    Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
    Cookie Name_ga, _ga_*, _gat,_gat_*,_gid, GOOGLE_ABUSE_EXEMPTION, AEC, __Secure-ENID, SOCS, CONSENT
    Cookie ExpirySession / 2 Years
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderHotjar Ltd., Dragonara Business Centre, 5th Floor, Dragonara Road, Paceville St Julian's STJ 3141 Malta
    PurposeHotjar is an user behavior analytic tool by Hotjar Ltd.. We use Hotjar to understand how users interact with our website.
    Privacy Policy https://www.hotjar.com/legal/policies/privacy/
    Host(s)*.hotjar.com
    Cookie Name_hjClosedSurveyInvites, _hjDonePolls, _hjMinimizedPolls, _hjDoneTestersWidgets, _hjIncludedInSample, _hjShownFeedbackMessage, _hjid, _hjRecordingLastActivity, hjTLDTest, _hjUserAttributesHash, _hjCachedUserAttributes, _hjLocalStorageTest, _hjptid, _hjSessionUser_2229986, _hjIncludedInPageviewSample, _hjIncludedInSessionSample, _hjAbsoluteSessionInProgress, _hjFirstSeen
    Cookie ExpirySession / 1 Year
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website
    PurposeVWO is AB Testing software that we'll use to test different elements of the website - form placement, nav, different page layouts, etc.
    Privacy Policy https://vwo.com/compliance/cookies-notice/
    Host(s).skai.io, dev.visualwebsiteoptimizer.com
    Cookie Name_vis_opt_exp_{CAMPAIGNID}_goal_{GOALID}, _vis_opt_test_cookie, _vis_opt_exp_{CAMPAIGNID}_combi, _vis_opt_exp_{CAMPAIGNID}_exclude, _vis_opt_exp_{CAMPAIGNID}_split, _vis_opt_s, _vis_opt_out, _vwo_uuid, _vwo_uuid_{CAMPAIGNID}, _vwo_ds, _vwo_sn, _vwo_uuid_v2, _vis_opt_exp_{CAMPAIGNID}_combi_choose, _vwo_referrer, _vwo, _vwo_global_opt_out, _vwo_ssm, uuid
    Cookie ExpirySession / 10 Years

    Marketing cookies are used by third-party advertisers or publishers to display personalized ads. They do this by tracking visitors across websites.

    Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

    Accept
    Name
    ProviderPardot
    PurposeCookie name associated with services from marketing automation and lead generation platform Pardot. The visitor value is the visitor_id in your Pardot account. This cookie is set for visitors by the Pardot tracking code.
    Host(s).pardot.com, pi.pardot.com, skai.io
    Cookie Namepardot, visitor_id*, lpv*
    Cookie ExpirySession / 10 Years
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderMeta Platforms Ireland Limited, 4 Grand Canal Square, Dublin 2, Ireland
    PurposeCookie by Facebook used for website analytics, ad targeting, and ad measurement.
    Privacy Policy https://www.facebook.com/policies/cookies
    Cookie Name_fbp,act,c_user,datr,fr,tr,m_pixel_ration,pl,presence,sb,spin,wd,xs
    Cookie ExpirySession / 1 Year
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderLinkedin
    Cookie Namelidc, li_gc, lang, AnalyticsSyncHistory, UserMatchHistory, li_sugr, bcookie, TDCPM, TDID, bscookie, ln_or
    Cookie ExpirySession / 1 Year
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderSkai
    Cookie Nameken_gclid
    Accept
    Name
    Provider6sense
    Cookie Name_gd_session, _an_uid, _gd_visitor, _gd_svisitor, 6suuid
    Cookie ExpirySession / 400 Days
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderGoogle Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
    PurposeCookie by Google used for conversion tracking of Google Ads.
    Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
    Cookie NameIDE, 1P_JAR, NID, _gcl_au, OTZ, test_cookie
    Cookie ExpirySession / 400 Days
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderOwner of this website
    Cookie NamePHPSESSID, sid, okto-autoposter-XXX, oktgid, oktsid, oktlogid-XXX, oktolead-XXX-Email, oktolead-XXX-Company, oktolead-XXX-FirstName, oktolead-XXX-LastName, oktolead-XXX-Phone, oktolead-XXX-Country, oktolead-XXX-Url, oktolead-XXX-State, oktolead-XXX-Comment, optout
    Cookie ExpirySession / 2 Years

    Content from video platforms and social media platforms is blocked by default. If External Media cookies are accepted, access to those contents no longer requires manual consent.

    Show Cookie Information Hide Cookie Information

    Accept
    Name
    ProviderWistia
    Host(s).wistia.com
    Cookie Namecb_anonymous_id, _sp_ses.2b40, _li_dcdm_c, __hssrc, _gcl_au, _clsk, hubspotutk, _sp_id.2b40, __hssc, __hstc, _uetsid, _uetvid, _gid, _ga, _ga_GQR109DZ3Y, _lc2, fpi, _ex-pricing-cta, _fbp, cb_group_id, cb_user_id, _clck
    Cookie ExpirySession / 400 Days
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderMeta Platforms Ireland Limited, 4 Grand Canal Square, Dublin 2, Ireland
    PurposeUsed to unblock Instagram content.
    Privacy Policy https://www.instagram.com/legal/privacy/
    Host(s).instagram.com
    Cookie Namepigeon_state
    Cookie ExpirySession
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderOpenstreetmap Foundation, St John’s Innovation Centre, Cowley Road, Cambridge CB4 0WS, United Kingdom
    PurposeUsed to unblock OpenStreetMap content.
    Privacy Policy https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Privacy_Policy
    Host(s).openstreetmap.org
    Cookie Name_osm_location, _osm_session, _osm_totp_token, _osm_welcome, _pk_id., _pk_ref., _pk_ses., qos_token
    Cookie Expiry1-10 Years
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderTwitter International Company, One Cumberland Place, Fenian Street, Dublin 2, D02 AX07, Ireland
    PurposeUsed to unblock Twitter content.
    Privacy Policy https://twitter.com/privacy
    Host(s).twimg.com, .twitter.com
    Cookie Name__widgetsettings, local_storage_support_test
    Cookie ExpiryUnlimited
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderVimeo Inc., 555 West 18th Street, New York, New York 10011, USA
    PurposeUsed to unblock Vimeo content.
    Privacy Policy https://vimeo.com/privacy
    Host(s)player.vimeo.com
    Cookie Namevuid
    Cookie Expiry2 Years
    Accept
    Name
    ProviderGoogle Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland
    PurposeUsed to unblock YouTube content.
    Privacy Policy https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en&gl=en
    Host(s)google.com
    Cookie NameCONSENT
    Cookie Expiry6 Month

    Borlabs Cookie powered by Borlabs Cookie

    Privacy Policy Imprint